A Marion County judge has ruled that three Pike Township Board members had no legal authority to hire their own lawyers at township expense. He voided the 2025 board resolution that made the hire and ordered the members to end the arrangement.

Marion Superior Court Judge Timothy Oakes on Friday granted summary judgment to Pike Township on its crossclaim against board members Kenya Perkins, Demetrice Hicks and Claudette Peterson. He denied the board members’ competing motion for summary judgment. The order was signed and filed Nov. 20.

At issue was a May 20, 2025, resolution in which the board retained McNeely Law as its own general counsel, to be paid from township funds.

Oakes found the board lacked the statutory authority to pass the resolution and declared it void from the start. Under the order, the resolution created no binding attorney-client relationship or contract between the township and the firm. It also created no obligation for the township to pay McNeely Law with public money.

The judge permanently barred the three members, in their official capacities, from carrying out the resolution. That includes directing McNeely Law as township or board counsel and paying the firm from township funds. He also ordered the members to take whatever official action is needed to rescind the resolution and end the engagement.

Oakes found no genuine dispute of material fact on any of the township’s three counts, which sought a declaratory judgment, a permanent injunction and a mandate.

The judge entered the ruling as a final judgment under Indiana Trial Rule 54(B), finding no just reason for delay. That makes the decision appealable now. A notice of appeal or a motion to correct error would be due within 30 days. Because the 30th day falls on a Sunday, the deadline is Monday, Dec. 21.

The township, represented by Jeffrey Bellamy of Thrasher Buschmann & Voelkel, argued that state law gives the power to hire a township attorney to the trustee, not the board. It cited Indiana Code 36-6-4-4. Annette Johnson is the Pike Township trustee.

The board members, represented by Bradley Buchheit and Brient Hicks of McNeely Law, argued that Indiana’s Home Rule law gave the board the power to hire its own counsel. They also argued the resolution was intended to provide a defense for board members who had been sued personally.

The two sides argued their motions before Oakes on Nov. 17.

The township filed the crossclaim on Oct. 3, 2025, as part of a lawsuit filed in May 2025 against the township and the three board members.

Friday’s order does not resolve the underlying complaint, which remains pending. The order states the court will set a hearing on it if any party requests one. A motion to dismiss filed by the individual board members in August 2025 also remains pending.

The order’s restrictions apply to McNeely Law’s role as township or board counsel paid with public funds. The firm’s attorneys have represented the three members in their individual capacities in the underlying suit since July 2025.

The board and Johnson have clashed this year over the budget, personnel records and the trustee’s reports to the board. In July, Hicks, the board president, sent Johnson a series of written demands, including one for every current township job description and pay rate.

Hicks and Peterson both lost primaries in May. Hicks finished second in the Democratic primary for Senate District 29, with about 26 percent of the vote to Kristina Moorhead’s 51 percent. Peterson lost the Democratic primary for trustee to Johnson, who won renomination with about 57 percent.


Disclosure: Indy Politics Editor and Publisher Abdul-Hakim Shabazz filed the underlying complaint in this case, Shabazz v. Pike Township, et al., Cause No. 49D02-2505-MI-024945, in Marion Superior Court 2. Perkins, Hicks and Peterson are named defendants.