by Abdul-Hakim Shabazz, Esq.
Doris Kearns Goodwin wrote the book on how Abraham Lincoln stocked his cabinet with the men who tried to beat him. So there’s something poetic about Beau Bayh’s first real move as Secretary of State-elect: bringing in the guy who ran against him on the Lincoln Party ticket.
On Wednesday, Bayh released a list of 17 transition advisers. Former Indianapolis Mayor Greg Ballard, who pulled about 4 percent as the Lincoln Party nominee, is on it. So is Dave Shelton, the Republican Knox County clerk who finished second to Max Engling at the GOP convention. Add former House Speaker John Gregg, Indiana AFL-CIO President Brett Voorhies and West Lafayette Mayor Erin Easter. Then come two names straight out of the 1990s: lobbyist Miriam Dant, who worked for then-Gov. Evan Bayh, and Bill Moreau, Evan Bayh’s old chief of staff and now publisher of the Indiana Citizen. Peter Hanscom, a longtime Joe Donnelly aide, runs the operation and becomes chief of staff Jan. 1.
Bayh says he wants it understood that the office “will not be run in a partisan manner.” Ballard says Bayh is following through on his campaign rhetoric and calls that “terrific.” Diego Morales is, in Bayh’s words, “cooperative to date.” Gov. Mike Braun picked up the phone. Everybody is playing nice.
Well, almost everybody.
Want to know who’ll grumble about this list? Don’t look at the Republicans. They’re still too busy pointing fingers at each other over who lost the Secretary of State’s office to have any room to complain about who’s helping Bayh move in. Look to Bayh’s left.
Democrats just won their first statewide race since 2012. They did it in part because the party fielded candidates almost everywhere and the grassroots showed up: the volunteers, the activists, the folks who spent four years hollering about Morales. And the first thing the winner does is hand the marquee seats to a Republican county clerk, a former Republican mayor, a Statehouse lobbyist and his dad’s old chief of staff.
To some on the left, that’s not a team of rivals, that’s a family reunion with a couple of Republicans invited for the potato salad.
It also feeds the fear progressives had about Beau from the jump: that he’s Evan 2.0. Evan Bayh built a career as the Democrat Republicans could live with, and the left never fully forgave him for it. The centrist votes. The abrupt 2010 exit. The post-Senate gigs at a D.C. law firm and on Fox News. Younger Democrats hoped Beau was a new generation. This list suggests they’re getting the old playbook with a fresher face.
To be fair, the playbook works. Labor has a seat with Voorhies. The transition is paid for by a PAC funded with a transfer from Bayh’s campaign committee, which he contrasted with the donor-secret nonprofits Braun and others have used. He has pledged no campaign donor will get a contract from the office. And Shelton isn’t some random Republican. He’s the guy who took Engling to the Indiana Election Commission over campaign money. For a guy promising to clean up the office, that’s a pretty good get.
But politics isn’t just about what works. It’s about who feels like they got paid. Republicans lost the office and got a seat at the table anyway. Progressives won the office and got a press release about bipartisanship.
The irony is that Republicans are the ones who should really be worried. A Secretary of State who governs from the middle with Republicans on his team is a lot harder to beat in 2030 than a partisan one. That’s a problem for later. The complaining starts this week.
I used to live in Springfield, Ill., so I know a thing or two about Lincoln. You can’t buy a cup of coffee in that town without getting a history lesson. And one of the lessons is that Lincoln had the same problem. The loudest critics of his team of rivals weren’t the Democrats. They were the Radical Republicans, the left wing of his own party, who thought he was too cautious, too accommodating and too willing to make nice with people they considered the enemy. A century and a half later, Barack Obama read the same book, put Hillary Clinton and a couple of Republicans in his cabinet, and spent the next two years hearing about it from what his own press secretary called the “professional left.” Sound familiar?
The more things change.
Abdul-Hakim Shabazz is the editor and publisher of IndyPolitics.org and an attorney licensed in Indiana and Illinois. He also writes a column for the Indiana Citizen, whose publisher is on Bayh’s transition team.