The Clark County Democratic Party has filed a lawsuit over what it calls ballot discrepancies in the Nov. 3 election. The suit asks a court to block certification of the Senate District 45 results and to keep Sen. Chris Garten (R-Charlestown) from being sworn in until the Indiana Recount Commission rules.
According to an Indiana Democratic Party news release issued Monday, the suit names the Clark County Election Board, the Clark County Clerk and Garten as respondents. The party said the lawsuit is separate from a recount or contest action, which it has not yet filed.
The suit asks for three things:
- Judicial review of the Election Board’s Nov. 10 resolution. The Democrats are asking under IC 3-6-5-34. In that resolution, the Board found it had examined the ballot sheets, poll pads and precinct results, that the information was reconciled, and that it had no authority to open the ballot containers. According to the release, the Board’s Democratic member said on the record that the resolution adopted a “false narrative.” The release says his motions to hand-count the ballots, and to run them through a machine tabulator just to get a total ballot count, both died for lack of a second.
- A preliminary injunction against the Board and the Clerk. It would stop them from certifying the SD 45 results, and from sending Clark County’s certification statement to the Indiana Election Division, until the Recount Commission makes its final determination.
- A preliminary injunction against Garten. It would bar him from being sworn in or seated until the Recount Commission makes its final determination.
Clark County Democratic Party Chair Miguel Hampton, Indiana Democratic Party Chair Karen Tallian and Ninth District Democratic Chair Adam Dickey released a joint statement.
“The Clark County Election Board left us with no other option but to resolve this issue in the courts,” the statement said. “Every person involved in this situation agrees there were significant issues with the election. The only disagreement is whether or not we should look into it.”
The statement also said other counties had “minor election irregularities requiring action,” but none where the local board “has put up quite so much resistance.” It added that the fact the race “affects one of the most powerful Republicans in state government makes this situation unique.”